Fishback 2028: Confession, Retraction, and “I’m Only Kidding”

James Fishback has had a busy autumn for a man who lost. In the span of a few weeks the former Florida gubernatorial hopeful withheld his endorsement from the nominee, went to confession, publicly retracted a bombshell he’d dropped on two sitting congressmen, and then announced a run for president, with a punchline.

Longtime readers will remember Fishback from our look at his “Simping and Sinning” tax proposal. The man has never been short on ideas. Votes are another matter.

Florida Historic Capitol and State Capitol in Tallahassee
Florida’s Historic Capitol and the Florida State Capitol in Tallahassee. Photo: DXR via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.

The Loss

Byron Donalds won the August 18 Republican primary with 47.8 percent, Newsweek reports. Lt. Gov. Jay Collins took 25.2 percent. Fishback finished third with 10.5 percent, or 177,809 votes in the certified state results.

The Non-Endorsement

Fellow primary candidates Collins and Renner quickly endorsed Donalds, per Florida Politics via the Miami Times. Fishback did not. “Today, I am witholding my endorsement of Byron Donalds,” he wrote, according to The Floridian, saying Donalds’ “choice to attack the nearly 200,000 Floridians who supported our campaign does not help Republicans win on November 3rd.”

The trigger was a Politico clip in which Donalds, told that one in ten primary voters backed Fishback, said “I don’t care.” Donalds says that was cut short: “What I actually said was: I don’t care who you voted for in the primary,” he wrote. Fishback named his price: end Flock cameras and license-plate readers, bar H-1B hiring by state agencies and contractors, and impose a moratorium on hyperscale AI data centers.

Some of his voters apparently didn’t wait for a deal. The Palm Beach Post reported in October that some Fishback supporters are crossing party lines to vote for Democrat David Jolly. (We couldn’t get past the Post’s paywall, so we’re citing the headline only.)

Official portrait of Rep. Byron Donalds
Rep. Byron Donalds, official 117th Congress portrait. Photo: United States Congress, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

The Confession

In early August, Fishback claimed Donalds and Rep. Cory Mills were under federal investigation, tied to alleged 2024 trips to the MGM National Harbor resort, Newsweek recounts. The Justice Department publicly said Donalds was not under investigation; a law enforcement official called the allegation “absolutely false.”

On October 28, Fishback took it back. “I made a terrible mistake,” he wrote, saying he’d gotten the information “from someone I trusted” and now accepted that neither man was under investigation, “which means that I bore false witness.” He said he retracted “after speaking with my priest and going to confession,” and that he wrote it “without consulting my lawyer.”

Credit where due: public retractions are rare in politics. Then again, so is accusing your primary opponent of being part of a “federal sex trafficking” conspiracy, as the Miami Times reported he did, on top of calling Donalds a “DEI Republican.”

“I’m Only Kidding”

The same day, absolution apparently secured, he moved on to bigger things. “Last night, someone asked me ‘What do you plan on doing next?’ I told them the truth. I’m running for president,” he posted. The 41-second clip, The Hill notes, ends with him saying, “I’m only kidding.” He told The Hill he and his wife will hold town halls in Iowa, New Hampshire and South Carolina before a “final decision.”

One small problem. Newsmax reported, per The Hill, that he was born January 1, 1995, making him 34 on Inauguration Day 2029. The Constitution requires a president to be 35. Fishback’s answer: “I have not formally declared for any office,” but “you can in fact win the presidency at 34,” with the vice president acting until you turn 35, citing the 20th Amendment. That’s his reading; we’ll leave it to the con-law crowd.

Confession, retraction, and a campaign he says is a joke but won’t quite call one. Florida’s third-place finisher has found his lane. It’s just not clear it leads anywhere.