Chief U.S. District Judge James E. Boasberg ordered the Justice Department to turn over redacted copies of the sealed search-warrant docket from the October search of Rep. Ilhan Omar’s Washington, D.C., home, and said the court will post those records no earlier than 5 p.m. on Nov. 23 unless a stay is granted. A 67-page affidavit that supported the warrant will stay sealed for now. Omar has not been charged.
The minute order, entered Nov. 17 in In re Application of Fourteen Press Organizations for Access to Sealed Search Warrant Records, case no. 1:26-mc-00144-JEB, directs the government to submit, by Nov. 20, all documents on the search-warrant docket — “excluding the search-warrant affidavit, but including the docket sheet” — in both redacted and “redboxed” form for the court to review. News organizations may challenge the redactions by Nov. 30. Boasberg said the court “will not publish any redacted material without speaking to the Government first.”
Homeland Security Investigations agents searched Omar’s Washington residence on Oct. 12 and carried boxes out of the house. The Minnesota Star Tribune, which was among the news organizations that asked for the records, has reported that the investigation concerns potential fraud involving her family’s immigration paperwork. MPR News reported that agents also seized her cell phone, laptop, notebooks and passport. Omar, a Minnesota Democrat, won a fifth term in the midterm election three weeks after the search.
What will and will not come out
At the Nov. 17 hearing, Boasberg was skeptical of keeping legal filings and court orders secret, and he was particularly doubtful about sealing arguments over the Constitution’s Speech or Debate Clause, which protects members of Congress from certain inquiries into their legislative work, the Star Tribune reported. He indicated the search warrant itself, including portions describing the general scope of the search, could be released with redactions.
He sided with the Justice Department on the affidavit. CBS Minnesota reported that Boasberg said “the vast majority” of that 67-page document should remain under seal for now, and that releasing it would be “premature,” though both he and the government agreed it will be unsealed at some point. The government has argued the affidavit would reveal investigative techniques, witness names and other law-enforcement information.
Prosecutors had opposed unsealing while the investigation is open and before a charging decision. U.S. Attorney Jeanine Pirro wrote that “unsealing everything now imperils the investigation,” the Star Tribune reported. In court, the government also argued the warrant had not been fully executed because agents were still reviewing seized materials. Boasberg noted the warrant had already been returned as executed. “I don’t think I buy” that argument, he said. A government lawyer told the judge the solicitor general could consider an appeal.
Boasberg separately gave the government until Nov. 23 to explain whether records in a related sealed matter, docketed as 26-mc-159, should be treated differently. MPR News described that case as one in which Omar is asking for seized property to be returned.
She has not been charged
The applicants include the Star Tribune, The New York Times and Judicial Watch, among more than a dozen organizations. They have cited, in court papers, “the enormous public interest in and historic significance of a search warrant executed at the home of a sitting member of Congress.” Nothing in the public record to date includes a criminal charge against Omar, and the Justice Department has said a charging decision has not been announced.




